skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

Ordered take out -- a small cheese stuffed pizza and an extra large pepperoni pizza with regular cru
Ordered take out -- a small cheese stuffed pizza and an extra large pepperoni pizza with regular crust. Their stuffed pizza is absolutely delicious! For a small order, it definitely packs a punch. The regular pizza is ok, but I love the crust!
Rozet S. via yelp.com - Jan 14, 2022
Pricey for a pizza... But it was delicious ... read more
kyle greene via google.com - Jan 13, 2022
Probably the best pizza in the state!
Paul Rox via google.com - Jan 5, 2022
I honestly think they have the The yummiest chicken Caesar salad and their dressing for the salad is delicious they also have steak and cheese sandwiches I also think it’s one of their best you should try it out you wouldn’t regret it ... read more
kalumbo via google.com - Jan 4, 2022
Grew up on southside of Chicago and in New England 10 years. The stuffed pizza is dead on Giorodanos or Lous. Thins crust is legit and its square cut without having to ask.
Martin Gollogly via google.com - Dec 30, 2021
Great food ... read more
Jimmie Gramajo via google.com - Dec 20, 2021
Better than any deep dish I've had in Chicago ... read more
Joseph Hines via google.com - Dec 15, 2021
Great Thin Crust Pizza!!! You won’t be disappointed.
Jaime Catalano via google.com - Dec 11, 2021
Ordered delivery once so far. I was pretty impressed by the quality of the pizza, the order was hot
Ordered delivery once so far. I was pretty impressed by the quality of the pizza, the order was hot and the wing dings were delish too. I don't have any complaints. Got my picky child to even try the pepperoni pizza and he enjoyed it as well. Cheese on the pizza was melty and stringy, sauce was perfect not too tangy and dough was fre ... read more
Christine S. via yelp.com - Dec 11, 2021
I found the pizza to be one of the best I've ever had my fiancé agrees. Sicilias is very good on del
I found the pizza to be one of the best I've ever had my fiancé agrees. Sicilias is very good on delivery but I find very expensive almost twice as much for a pizza as anywhere else it is twice as good but you're paying for every bit of it. Last night we had all baby pies stuffed 1. Stuffed cheese #2. Stuffed cheese and pepperoni #3 ... read more
Chris C. via yelp.com - Dec 11, 2021
The stuffed pizza is amazing , the price is a bit expensive though ... read more
Jose Santos via google.com - Dec 4, 2021
Great food and service. Rare place that serves deep dish pizzas ... read more
Ojas Mehta via google.com - Dec 1, 2021
Sicilia's pizza is a meal in a box. When you feel the box, you know it's packed with good stuff. Great pizza, even good when cold!
Frank DeAngelis via google.com - Nov 27, 2021
Angela the waitress is so nice. They remodeled the inside and it looks great! The stuffed pizza is fabulous and they also have an extensive menu of you're in the mood for something else. I recommend this establishment.
Vellentie fam Vellentie via google.com - Nov 16, 2021
Decent pizza and pitchers of beer. Newly renovated. Nice location right on Atwell’s Avenue within walking distance to the Square, dessert and parking nearby.
Melissa Devine via google.com - Nov 13, 2021
Uno de los lugares que guardare en mi memoria pues fui con personas muy agradables ... read more
JANINA ZAVALA via google.com - Nov 13, 2021
Took the 1 hr drive down from Malden, Ma. again. The new sign and beautifully renovated interior along with the Best Pizza on the Planet made it worth every minute but I cannot say enough Great things about the Awesome waiter we had. I'm horrible with names but I believe it was Wayne. Very attentive and extremely personable. My 8 yr ... read more
Steve O'Connell via google.com - Nov 9, 2021
Took the 1 hr drive down from Malden, Ma. again. The new sign and beautifully renovated interior alo
Took the 1 hr drive down from Malden, Ma. again. The new sign and beautifully renovated interior along with the Best Pizza on the Planet made it worth every minute but I cannot say enough Great things about the Awesome waiter we had. I'm horrible with names but I believe it was Wayne. Very attentive and extremely personable. My 8 yr ... read more
John D. via yelp.com - Nov 9, 2021
The best calzon ever also the stuffed pizza is incredible good ... read more
jose d valdez m via google.com - Oct 31, 2021
Best pizza! We got the stuffed pizza and it did not disappoint! Newly renovated and the staff are al
Best pizza! We got the stuffed pizza and it did not disappoint! Newly renovated and the staff are all friendly and overly welcoming. We love going here!
Chloe S. via yelp.com - Oct 23, 2021
Amazing pizza ... read more
Linda Millar via google.com - Oct 18, 2021
First time visit the steak & cheese sandwich was delish!!
First time visit the steak & cheese sandwich was delish!!
Beth Palmer-Benton via facebook.com - Oct 15, 2021
Updated interior, but the food is just as good as before. Looking forward to visiting very often.
Justin Stockard via google.com - Oct 14, 2021
Good late night food ! Newly renovated looks great in here !
M White via google.com - Oct 12, 2021
Good food, open late, the remodel looks nice!
Ocean State Drifters inc via google.com - Oct 12, 2021
Renovated and so modern and beautiful inside. Yolla is the best waitress I’ve ever had in my life, stuffed cheese pizza was delicious.
Bianca Cipriano via google.com - Oct 11, 2021
Decent place to grab a slice but I wasn't overly impressed. Maybe I was expecting a bit more given t
Decent place to grab a slice but I wasn't overly impressed. Maybe I was expecting a bit more given the Federal Hill location. It was good but nothing exceptional. What was great though was that we walked right in, were quickly helped, ordered the slices and they appeared super fast. Nice open air seating in the window with some good ... read more
Sarah A. via yelp.com - Oct 7, 2021
My sandwich go to place. Busy shop, so freshness isn't an issue. In regards to their bread anyway. Had a chix cutlet, once. Why? Once?. I wouldn't pay for it again. Prices are different depending on who's working. It's usually by a $1 or $2. But they should realize ppl aren't stupid and DO pay attention. I hope it's not nefarious. T ... read more
Darryl H via google.com - Oct 6, 2021
Good service good food ... read more
james taylor via google.com - Sep 11, 2021
As a person who is Chicagoan born and raised I must say no one in Rhode Island has come close to nailing that Chicago pizza taste for me but Sicilia’s did more than nail it they hit the nail on the head if you are looking for authentic Chicago style deep dish pizza go here ... read more
Racheal Henderson via google.com - Sep 3, 2021
I love the pizza but it just cost a lot I get just a pizza and some fries and it was $31 for deliver
I love the pizza but it just cost a lot I get just a pizza and some fries and it was $31 for delivery online through yelp otherwise Annette I love the pizza it was really really good and my grandson love the fries I will definitely order again but I will call not go online.
Lisa J. via yelp.com - Aug 25, 2021
I’m from Chicago o eat here all ...
I’m from Chicago o eat here all the time. I’ve never had a bad pizza there thin crust is a Chicago thin crust you can go to 5 different places in Chicago and get different crust. And the deep dish I’ll get a giordanos and one of there’s and you won’t tell the difference it’s better than eating pan pizza that every restaurant serves o ... read more
John M. via yellowpages.com - Aug 17, 2021
We were looking for a different pizza of sorts and I came upon their online recommendations. So I we
We were looking for a different pizza of sorts and I came upon their online recommendations. So I went in and ordered a Famous Stuffed Pizza to go. Although it was beautifully prepared and presented, the pizza just lacked depth of flavor. And even though we got the Meat Lovers version, we could not taste any of the meat as all we tas ... read more
Will F. via yelp.com - Aug 14, 2021
We were looking for a different pizza of sorts and I came upon their online recommendations. So I we
We were looking for a different pizza of sorts and I came upon their online recommendations. So I went in and ordered a Famous Stuffed Pizza to go. Although it was beautifully prepared and presented, the pizza just lacked depth of flavor. And even though we got the Meat Lovers version, we could not taste any of the meat as all we tas ... read more
wafernandez via tripadvisor.com - Aug 14, 2021
There is NO PLACE like it... Amazing ... read more
DaRiddledOne 77 via google.com - Aug 2, 2021
The ONLY mom and pop resturant in the ENTIRE New England I’m aware of that makes Chicago Style or Deep Dish Pizza!! The pizza is unlike any other pizza, it’s done extremely well! For my cheese lovers get extra cheese!! The Lebanese brothers who own the resturant and all the workers are great people! You’ll leave happy and so will you ... read more
Haidar Halaoui Halloway via google.com - Jul 28, 2021
This is like a Chicago style pizza but I think they have a regular crust as well but you have to ask
This is like a Chicago style pizza but I think they have a regular crust as well but you have to ask. The toppings are really good and they do not skimp .tons of good stuff. The sauce is really good and has a very good taste. some places make it like a non tasty sauce. No here you know it is a real Italian sauce. Inside is nice and r ... read more
Barry N via tripadvisor.com - Jul 27, 2021
The deep dish pizza is excellent ... read more
JJ Buck via google.com - Jul 18, 2021
Great Chicago style pizza ... read more
Trinity the singing Wolamute via google.com - Jul 14, 2021
The pizza is okay. I ordered a pepperoni pizza to try this place out and it was decent, but this won
The pizza is okay. I ordered a pepperoni pizza to try this place out and it was decent, but this won't be my new regular pizza place.
Jen F. via yelp.com - Jul 13, 2021
The food was real good .
Vivian Robinson via google.com - Jul 8, 2021
Good late night food ... read more
M White via google.com - May 26, 2021
The food here is absolutely delicious. The calamari was tender and crisp, even after it was brought home. I'll definitely be dining from here again.
Victor Hanas via google.com - May 18, 2021
Great pizza! Highly recommend the margherita. Crispy and also the right balance of sauce and cheese.
Great pizza! Highly recommend the margherita. Crispy and also the right balance of sauce and cheese. Baked to perfection not too burnt or anything. Recommend this place for a good slice & some interesting pizza types.
Dina L. via yelp.com - May 16, 2021
Pizza was delicious, however I was told over the phone my order would be ready in 30 minutes and in actuality it was 50 minutes.
Casey Tallo via google.com - May 14, 2021
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire